How much would you pay for a 1-lb. lobster supper? Let's say $31.95 is the price for the lobster supper. Ready to order?
Well, $32 for a lobster supper is a bit of money, especially since a 1-lb. lobster doesn't generate even remotely close to a pound of lobster meat. After all, you can get a quality steak close to a pound for that price.
Okay, let's throw in a pound of steamed mussels with that 1-lb. lobster. That kicks up the incentive a bit.
Before we go any further, we should point out that you also get homemade rolls and bread; seafood chowder or beef vegetable soup; a garden salad, potato salad, and cole slaw; non-alcoholic beverage, and dessert.
Whether you think you're getting the value for that price, you do know that the price is a good one in the marketplace.
Oh, and there is one more thing. Except for the lobster, you can have as much of that food as you want … all for $32.
This is what I got at a lobster supper in New Glasgow, Prince Edward Island, Canada on my recent vacation.
All you can eat places sound wonderful, but don't always work in a world where overeating isn't as much fun as it used to be. But I hadn't had much to eat up until about 4 pm, and thought that experiencing a lobster supper was a great tradition to have while visiting the Maritimes.
Lobster suppers, based on my one and only appearance, attract an older crowd. The women who served us were well-dressed — very classy.
The game is then on. Get as much value as you can.
The rolls look really good, but you have to ignore them. They can wait until later. Soup and salad fill you up, and that is the strategy to stay healthy, but doesn't help you if you shooting for bang for the buck.
The seafood chowder was okay, but I had enough of cream-based soups that were more about potatoes than seafood. The garden salad was small, but fine. The cole slaw was pretty good. I had found incredible cole slaw in New Brunswick. This did not compare to them, but better than I usually find in a restaurant. There was a small scoop of potato salad that I ignored. Not worthy of my time.
The mussels came next. They were steamed. Even if you want to avoid alcohol, mussels taste better cooked in something. And the mussels suffered as a result. Going through the mussels became exercise, which stimulated more appetite. Quite a few of the mussels weren't opening, so they got thrown into the bucket with the opened shells. We did get melted butter to eat with the mussels. This was not a garnish I associated with mussels. Still, the mussels were good, just not as good as cooking them in something other than water.
The main course came next. A 1-lb. lobster. The lobster was split open, so you didn't need a lobster cracker to pull apart various places. You did get a lobster fork for pulling out the meat. Your placemat had instructions on how to get the most meat out of your lobster. Nothing like instructions to improve your chances at getting the lobster.
The waitress took away the melted butter that I got with the mussels. A point of order: Never, ever take away melted butter from my table. If there is a drop left, I will eat it. I got more melted butter, but since I was incorporating the rolls into the melted butter, the butter soon ran out.
Nothing is sadder than having lobster without enough melted butter. Tracking down melted butter took longer than I had hoped. Though the busboy who helped me out gave me more than the waitress did.
Getting a break did help my digestion, so perhaps a blessing in disguise (warning: don't try that again. I want my melted butter).
Dessert was the final mark. Since I had ordered a glass of milk, I needed something proper to go with that. Yes, ordering milk with shellfish sounded so wrong (and I'm not Jewish), but I wanted the milk on principle since I got a non-alcoholic beverage with the meal.
I ordered blueberry pie and chocolate ice cream. The desserts were, um, let's be kind and say not homemade. The ice cream still had a little freezer burn. Still, dessert was dessert and was pretty good.
Of course, at any point, I could have had seconds, but wanted to see if I could finish one serving of everything and still be hungry. The waitress asked if I wanted something more. Mussels? Salad? More dessert?
Since I had the extra melted butter, I asked for another roll. The rolls were actually quite good, and the idea of a hot roll with melted butter was just how I wanted to finish the meal.
The total cost, including tax and tip, was about $42. I didn't eat anything else than night. And if you averaged out the cost of lunch and dinner, each meal averaged out to about $24/meal.
If dessert was as homemade as the rolls, if the mussels were steamed with a bit of flavor, the meal could have been off the charts. Still, a 1-lb. lobster meal is going to cost you quite a bit no matter where you go and how you pull it off. This meal did have value, not just monetarily, but as an unique and enjoyable experience.
While I can't do all-you-can-eat places on a regular basis, this was a nice way to dip my toes back in the practice. The meal was balanced, if you ignore the dessert. The memory of the lobster supper will last long after the calories have been burned off, and that is ultimately what matters.