Tallow Fries now in Ohio, Colorado, Florida, Texas and Oklahoma
— Steak 'n Shake (@SteaknShake) February 25, 2025
By March 1 ALL locations. Fries will be RFK’d! pic.twitter.com/m3pVaulppW
We are not on the horns of a dilemma in that the choice in front of us is not a situation in which one has to choose between things that are unpleasant or undesirable. On the surface, French fries cooked in beef tallow is pleasant or desirable.
Steak 'n Shake fries played into the new reign of the very dangerous Health and Human Services secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. This is where the dilemma resides.
The fast food chain announced switches from vegetable oil to beef tallow on the concept that beef tallow is better for you than vegetable oil. The influence of a very dangerous person.
Sweetgreen is offering a contrast: Ripple Fries air-fried in avocado oil and seasoned with a blend of salt and herbs.
My local Steak 'n Shake in my area had no signage about the beef tallow in the French fries. Then again, I am not in RFK Jr. territory.
I can contrast the current product with the previous version cooked in vegetable oil. The regular French fries are really good. Yes, the beef tallow did improve the taste. The quality of the beef tallow could be better but yes, there is a taste difference and a positive one.
We chased after McDonald's for years to convert to a fat free of trans fat. Reportedly, McDonald's used beef tallow at one point, which upset Hindus and vegans, among many groups. That fast food chain finally did come up with a fat that was trans fat free but the taste suffered as a result.
Your humble narrator adores Steak 'n Shake French fries even in vegetable oil as a contrast to the tasteless McDonald's fries. Always try a few fries without ketchup to see if the actual fries are tasty. Both versions of Steak 'n Shake blow away what comes out of McDonald's.
The beef tallow McDonald's fries would be a serious contender. The criticism of McDonald's was that they used it while hiding that information from vegans and Hindus, among others. Steak 'n Shake customers are entitled to that same transparency. Our dismal experience with a hipster place in San Francisco advertising "duck fat fries" that were not cooked in duck fat reminds us that transparency and ethics are important.
Cutting way back on major label fast food
Steak 'n Shake switching to trans fat free oils
Hipster vs. Classic: sincerity in ingredients
BalanceofFood.com fast food coverage
Steak 'n Shake is advertising the 100% beef tallow with the slogan: "America deserves the best." America clearly doesn't get the best, especially in fast food. The quality of beef tallow is likely a concern. You can buy better beef tallow and cook French fries in that at home and get a better product.
America's love of fast food, and not high-quality fast food, means the country gets what it deserves: not that much.
We know little of the history of Steak 'n Shake in terms of trans fat free oil options. We covered this story in 2007 and even then, details were vague.
I don't eat too many French fries these days so if I am torn, fries cooked even in cheap beef tallow could break a tie.
I live a lot closer to a Sweetgreen. Despite my love for healthy food, I rarely go to Sweetgreen. Too expensive and sometimes too healthy.
Their brand new Ripple Fries, air-fried in avocado oil and seasoned with a blend of salt and herbs, was opportune to measure its healthier approach. The advantages: Being air fried with very little oil and using avocado oil instead of a seed oil. Then again, less oil is used in air frying.
The location had plenty of obvious presence of the new Ripple Fries. The price point was $4.85 vs. $3.89 at Steak 'n Shake. I was worried that the portion would be too small but the portion size was decent.
ripple fries have entered the chat 🍟
— sweetgreen (@sweetgreen) March 4, 2025
let us introduce you to the good fry. made with five ingredients you can pronounce and air-fried in avocado oil.
pair it with pickle ketchup or garlic aioli. choose wisely. pic.twitter.com/Nl00l4z3vN
We used a local, sugar-based ketchup for the Steak 'n Shake fries while relying on Sweetgreen's choice of garlic aioli or pickle ketchup. The garlic aioli had more flavor than I thought it would. The pickle ketchup was okay, not tasting anything like pickles or ketchup.
The Sweetgreen fries are about what you would expect from an air fryer. Not really crispy but if you lower your standards, they would be fine. You think of that more as real potatoes instead of traditional French fries. A cross of chips, wedges, and fries.
They were better seasoned and felt more nutritious than the Steak 'n Shake. They can't live up to the Steak 'n Shake in consistency and taste yet a quality product on its own, especially with the garlic aioli.
One critique: I had to wait for the Steak 'n Shake fries but they came out hot. I got the Sweetgreen fries right away and they definitely weren't hot. Speed is fine but I can wait for hot fries — every single time.
Preserving the integrity of Belgian frites
Wendy's new natural fries delivers by major chain fast food standards
I don't have issues with vegetable oil, beef tallow, seed oils, and avocado oils. I can even deal with air fried as long as you don't accept that as actual fried. If I had a coupon for each one, I would get both of them. They each have good points and, with a hot fresh version of the Sweetgreen fries, would be a good snack choice.
I say this as a former French fry aficionado: enjoy fries. Eat quality fare. Not too much. Like Michael Pollan has said, cook them at home. Get quality beef tallow or duck fat. Air fry them with a bit of avocado oil. Just get them to be a bit more crisp.
Temptation of the Week: Size of the French fries
What's Tempting: 6 French fries
Temptation of the Week: French fries naked
Twitter captures: @SteaknShake; @sweetgreen
photos credit: me