If you hear the words Chicago and pizza, you might think of deep dish, a food that Jon Stewart described as "not pizza." Chicago has a style of pizza outside the tourist traps: tavern style pizza.
The Great Lakes region of the United States already has Detroit style pizza. Detroit style pizza is distinct from the auto parts container used to bake the pizzas to the unique cheese structure and the order for the ingredients.
Tavern style pizza is, well, pizza. The main distinction to tavern style pizza is, well, how the pizza is cut. The pieces are much smaller so you can put them on a bar napkin instead of using plates.
Somehow, Pizza Hut decided to copy the tavern-style pizza from Chicago. Why?
Tavern style pizza, unlike deep dish, is actual pizza. There are subtle nuances. The thin crust is truly thin and yeast is reportedly used. Most of what makes tavern style is how the pizza is cut.
Monica Eng, whom I know in real life, compares and contrasts the Pizza Hut version with a local version. I trust her take on the pizzas.
Your humble narrator hasn't tried either one but has had multiple tavern style pizzas over the years. Regular readers know your humble narrator has an intolerance to mozzarella cheese and might wonder how I could have had those pizzas over the last few decades. I had to figure this intolerance after not making the connection. So I have had tavern style pizza and it's just pizza cut in funny shapes.
Temptation of the Week: Out-of-town pizza through the eyes of Jon Stewart
Canadian film review: The Pizza City You've Never Heard Of (CanadianCrossing.com)
A lot of Detroit people ignore Windsor and Canada. Windsor has its own style of pizza that is very different from Detroit style pizza. A river and international border runs through the 2 pizzas.
I was skeptical about how distinct Windsor pizza would be from regular pizza. My Windsor friends swore this was different. The differences are there. The documentary we reviewed goes into those details.
- flour crust with cornmeal on the bottom
- sweet sauce using sweeter tomatoes such as San Marzano or tomatoes from California
- Galati cheese company making high fat mozzarella that is stringy when you pull out a slice
- shredded pepperoni
- canned mushrooms
The list shows a way more distinct pizza than tavern style pizza in Chicago. A thin crust and smaller pieces versus these significant differences. The Windsor style pizza is a lot more distinct than tavern style pizza. Of course, Pizza Hut, Canada or United States, will not cross the border to copy Windsor style pizza.
New Haven, CT style pizza is more distinct than Chicago tavern style pizza.
The point of Pizza Hut's newest pizza isn't to be innovative or imaginary. You likely haven't heard of tavern style pizza even if you have visited Chicago. Pizza nerds know yet not regular people.
You won't compare the differences. You know the national chain wouldn't come close to duplicating a local version of any food. Imagine a national chain trying to duplicate Cincinnati style chili or a Detroit coney dog.
Perhaps the Pizza Hut people got inspired by the obsession over The Bear TV show set in Chicago.
Everyone: Make us a true Chicago pizza
— Pizza Hut (@pizzahut) June 27, 2024
Us: YES, CHEF pic.twitter.com/nisTe2LW5G
The Bear mocks the basic sandwich establishment for another unneeded high-end restaurant
Cheap pizza comes to Canada but at what cost
What's Tempting: Getting the larger pizza
As we noted in a long ago time, travel to places to have the unique foods of a region. Detroit has its style pizza that is worth exploring as does Windsor, across the Detroit River in Canada. If that isn't practical, Cook's Country has a version you can try at home.
Come to Chicago for the hot dog, Italian beef sandwiches (trashed in The Bear), and perhaps the pizza and "not pizza." Don't come to Chicago just for tavern style pizza. If you come for other reasons, find out for yourself if tavern style pizza is distinct.
photo credit: Pizza Hut
video credit: The Daily Show with Jon Stewart/Comedy Central
Twitter capture: Pizza Hut