We wrote about the plan in British Columbia for a 3-year experiment to decriminalize certain drugs for a healthier policy on overdoses. About halfway through the experiment, the province, with the help of the federal government, is making some adjustments, mostly in the area of where people can consume those drugs.
We were a bit surprised — from a naive standpoint — about the strength of the rhetoric involving terms such as "failure" and "recriminalize." Marijuana is legal coast to coast to coast in Canada and the provinces have restrictions on where you can consume marijuana.
The changes stem from making sure the drugs are not consumed in public and other areas of note. The parallel is that the drug use isn't as much of an issue as where the drug use is happening. One key difference is that with homelessness as a factor of opioids that, unlike marijuana use, there isn't an "inside space" for easy consumption. Since Canada waited a long time with making edibles legal, and many restrictions on smoking inside rental apartments, drug policy happens in stages.
The Eby Government last fall passed a bill banning drug use in public spaces, such as parks, beaches, and transit. A BC Supreme Court judge ruled that the law would have "irreparable harm" to people who use drugs.
There are political elements at work for the changes. Federal opposition leader Pierre Poilievre referred to Justin Trudeau's policy (not his policy) as "wacko" in Parliament. That is allowed yet Poilievre also used that word about the prime minister, which got Poilievre tossed out of the House of Commons. Needless to say, a lot of money was raised as the stunt felt like just that, a stunt.
The province will have an election on or before October 19. Premier David Eby (New Democratic Party) have 55 seats in the current 87-seat parliament. The BC United Party is in opposition at 26 seats. The Green Party have 2 seats, Conservative Party have 2 seats, and there are 2 independents. The number of seats in October or earlier will be 93 seats.
The BC United (BCU) may seem new but this is the new name for what was the British Columbia Liberal Party (BC Liberals), which has not connection to the federal Liberals. The name change came on April 12, 2023. I remember in past trips having BC people explain that the "Liberals" had a lot of conservatives.
Eby, who had served as the attorney general under Premier John Horgan, took over for Horgan on November 18, 2022, and hasn't run for election as premier.
British Columbia decriminalizes some drugs but at a really low threshold
Canadian film review: Love in the Time of Fentanyl
Canadian film review: Kímmapiiyipitssini: The Meaning of Empathy
Despite what Poilievre and/or BC United might think, the fentanyl problem, overdoses (fatal and otherwise), opioids are a problem bigger than decriminalization. Decriminalization without housing help won't be as effective a solution. The safe supply issue, which is helping with overdoses, is making more progress than say Alberta's recovery-based solutions.
Toronto and Montréal also are looking into federal help for their drug areas. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is willing to work out solutions on a provincial level with Vancouver getting help only after British Columbia participated on a provincial level.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford, ironic given a number of drug-related allegations, won't agree to a safe supply position. Quebec Premier François Legault has not weighed in recently but has said "non" to the idea of decriminalization in the past.
This leaves British Columbia as the only option to learn what might be able to work. Needless to say, the experiment would be in jeopardy either in the 2024 provincial election or a 2025 federal election.
B.C. rolls back drug decriminalization (The Current on CBC Radio)
Backlash and walk backs: BC reverses drug policy (Front Burner)
We beg for political leadership to tackle difficult topics. We don't offer up that one solution will magically make the drug crisis in Canada go away. Those in the United States should praise what British Columbia is doing since they might benefit from the experiment in western Canada.
The other side has no solutions other than to stop this particular solution.
CanadianCrossing.com British Columbia coverage
CanadianCrossing.com film reviews
CanadianCrossing.com film coverage
Back in the days of the drive-in theatre where you could see 3 films in a row, we would recommend a triple feature of Love in the Time of Fentanyl, The Body Remembers When the World Broke Open, and Kímmapiiyipitssini: The Meaning of Empathy.
The 2 documentaries (Love and Kímmapiiyipitssini) are about finding solutions for the opioids crisis while the other film takes place in the area in Vancouver known for its drug use. Your humble narrator learned a lot from these films and enough to know there is a lot I don't know. These people need help and we should do what we can.
video and photo credit: CBC News